14

I have this well stocked pantry and have noticed a little bowing toward the center of the shelves. I’m worried that they may eventually collapse. Is this something to be worried about, or is this fine? If they need to be reinforced, what would be the best way to do it? I have a ton of tools, but am fairly light on DIY experience.

whole pantry whole pantry roughly half inch of sagging seen in paint paint separation between shelves paint separation on wall how all shelves are attached to the wall

Amazon Dies In Darkness
  • 2,749
  • 11
  • 45
  • 70
Colin
  • 243
  • 1
  • 5

7 Answers7

19

Significant improvement for $20 and one hour work

This is not THAT bad. Ya, it's bad. It could have been made with thicker shelves and constructed a little better. Rebuilding it would be rewarding but probably a waste of money. You can improve this significantly for about $20.

  1. In one of your photos, the ledger board is peeling away from the wall. You have tools? Use your stud finder (or buy one) to find all the studs, and put a #8x2" coarse thread screw into some critical studs -- wherever you see weak points, near the ends and middle of each board, etc. The more the merrier but you don't have to go crazy because they generally seem to be holding.
  2. Buy another piece of 1x4 or whatever that one leg is made of to create another leg in the middle of the long shelf. (Or buy white composite or white melamine so you don't have to paint it if you're not too fussy about color matching). Cut 3/4 inch notches to support the shelves from underneath. A few screws hold the new leg in place but do not support the shelves.

enter image description here

jay613
  • 49,543
  • 6
  • 70
  • 201
10

I have this well stocked pantry and have noticed a little bowing toward the center of the shelves. I’m worried that they may eventually collapse. Is this something to be worried about, or is this fine?

It's hard/impossible for us to know if they will ever collapse. To make an estimate, we need to know the type of wood, the age of the wood, and the environmental humidity. If that's new particle board in a humid environment, there's a good chance they will collapse. If that's old hardwood in a dry environment, it's unlikely they will collapse if you stock them properly.

The biggest issue is that you're stocking your shelves wrong. Put all heavy items on the ends of the shelves and towards the back, where the most support exists. No heavy cans in the front center. If you follow these simple guidelines, your shelves will last much longer, regardless of their composition.

If they need to be reinforced, what would be the best way to do it? I have a ton of tools, but am fairly light on DIY experience.

Adding shelf brackets is fairly quick, but you'll have to ensure the current supports are not particle board. If they are, you'll need to find the wall studs and anchor into them.

A quick tool-free solution is to invest in wire shelving. You can buy wire shelving of all different sizes and simply lay them on top of your existing wood shelves. Here is an example of a long shelf (I have no affiliation). Wire shelving comes in different gauges, and includes integrated lateral cross-support. If you buy wire shelving made of thick gauge wires and the shelves have effective integrated lateral cross-supports, they can handle a massive amount of weight. Most manufacturers will indicate the amount of weight their shelves can support.

Amazon Dies In Darkness
  • 2,749
  • 11
  • 45
  • 70
6

The easiest would be to add shelf brackets to add support.

The second easiest is to use thicker boards for the shelves, but unless thick enough, shelf brackets might still be needed.

Third would be to add wood under the shelf edges from end to end. Hardwood 1x2s might be enough at front and back.

crip659
  • 32,986
  • 2
  • 39
  • 85
4

You look like you're all set for the next siege!

Firstly, store the heavier objects towards the end of each shelf. That in itself will help stop the bowing.

Secondly, use vertical pieces of wood - perhaps the same as the shelves themselves.They need mounting from the bottom upwards, the full depth of each shelf. Merely sliding them in place under the next empty shelf will suffice, centrally.

Thirdly, you could use something like 3"x2" strips under each shelf, at its front, glued and screwed which would take out the bowing, and give strength across the whole width, left to right.

Fourthly, incorporate 2nd and 3rd ideas, making the vertical wood 2" less, front to back. Sort of belt and braces.

Tim
  • 5,501
  • 14
  • 31
3

The second-to-last picture makes it look like the boards (1x4 maybe) are pulling out from the wall. In my house someone made shelves like this by hammering finish nails into sheetrock. That will collapse for sure! If you have a studfinder you could start by driving screws through those boards (the ones flat on the wall) into studs.

nuggethead
  • 1,659
  • 1
  • 17
  • 31
1

Do you live in an earthquake zone? I'd be putting a small strip of wood across the front of each shelf such that there is a small lip upward. This will hold items on the shelves in a shake, and provide structural strength to the shelf.

Clear out the room, scrape the paint off the front of each shelf to expose the wood, and nail/glue strips of wood across the front as a batten. Thickness is about 5~8mm or quarter of an inch, and height such that the same is above the shelf.
You may need to jack up the shelf to take out bowing/sagging while the glue sets, so some of those reversible clamps can be handy here. Start from the bottom shelf and progress upward
Use single lengths of wood as batten, don't join shorter pieces to make the distance.
Once glue has dried, then either repaint or just varnish the exposed wood.

enter image description here

The lighting looks good in your photos - if it wasn't I'd be tempted to make the battens hang down about 10-15mm below the shelf, and install some low-voltage LED strips into the shaded area to help illuminate the dark back corners. I did this in my pantry, wired to a door switch and it make the world of difference.

An illuminated pantry with LED strips
Not mine - source: https://dondraper.com/2024/05/add-light-to-a-dark-pantry-with-led-strip-lighting/

Criggie
  • 11,950
  • 2
  • 26
  • 79
1

A generic fix: I have a similar set of shelves (50 years old now) and fortified them by attaching vertical supports in the center (left-to-right) of each shelf, down to the floor. These supports can be a piece of wood (mine are lathed/decorative) or an entire board that fits from the front of the shelf to the back wall.

kackle123
  • 393
  • 2
  • 5